Human Rights Conflicts in Afghan 2004 Constitution: Shariah vs. International Standards

Abstract

In the discourse of human rights, tension emerged from the full involvement of the Western countries led by the United States of America “USA” in the 2004 constitution of Afghanistan “The 2004 Constitution”. It focuses on human rights under Shariah and international standards without unifying conflicting ideas after the Bonn Agreement of 2001. Hence, human rights are considered a subject of controversy among Afghan legal experts, law enforcement authorities and international community. It led to the lack of the rule of law due to constitutional duality. To fulfil the legal gap, this research seeks to discover the real position of human rights by evaluating the tension between legal provisions on Shariah and international human rights standards in the 2004 constitution. The research employs the doctrinal method of textual analysis and coordinated constitutional interpretation to discover the opposing areas of human rights under the Shariah and international standards. The researcher examined the legal status of human rights under constitutional provisions on Shariah and international human rights instruments which are introduced as conflicting sources of law for fundamental human rights, particularly about religious freedom and gender equality. Additionally, the 2004 constitution weakens the position of Shariah by restricting the meaning of law which does not contain the constitution itself, and by considering the provisions of international human rights instruments to be equated to the constitutional provision in ranking. However, the 2004 constitution prefers international human rights instruments to Shariah in the case of conflict either in legislation or in the judiciary.ReferencesAbdul, Q. A & Latif, A. (2023). The Right to Education of a Child: A Comparison of Afghan Law on Protection of Child’s Rights and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. Cognizance Journal, 3(6), 443–448. https://doi.org/10.47760/cognizance.2023.v03i06.030.Agreement On Provisional Arrangements in Afghanistan Pending The Re-Establishment Of Permanent Government Institutions. (2001). OHCHR. https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2009/10/agreement-provisional-arrangements-afghanistan-pending-re-establishment.Ahmed, D. I., & Ginsburg, T. (2014). Constitutional Islamization and Human Rights: The Surprising Origin and Spread of Islamic Supremacy in Constitutions. Virginia Journal of International Law, 54(3), 615.Alireza, M & Mohammad, R. R. T. (2019). قانون احوال شخصیه شیعیان افغانستان و میزان همسویی با فقه جعفری (بخش میراث)[ The personal status of the Shiites in Afghanistan and the extent of its alignment with Jafari fiqh ( the Heritage section )] 2(1), 95–115. https://doi.org/10.34785/j016.2019.949Azimi. A. (2020). تعارض معاهدات بین المللی با قوانین در نظام حقوقی افغانستان  [the contradiction between international conventions and laws in the legal system of Afghanistan]. Adalat, 22(212), P 82-115.BBCPersian.com. (2024). The protests against the releastion of Abdul Raman. Bbc.com. https://www.bbc.com/persian/afghanistan/story/2006/03/printable/060327_he-afghanchristianCairo Declaration on Human Rights in Islam. (1990). Refworld. https://www.refworld.org/legal/resolution/oic/1990/en/13797Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice. (2008, March 30). https://www.unodc.org/pdf/criminal_justice/Note_by_the_Secretariat_on_Aspects_of_Violence_against_Women_that_Pertain_Directly_to_the_CCPCJ.pdfConstitutional Law and Human Rights International, Comparative and National Perspective. (2020). Max Planck Foundation for international Peace and the Rule of Law & Afghanistan Legal Research and Development Organization.Danish, S. (2009). حقوق اساسی افغانستان[The Constitutional Law of Afghanistan]. Abn Sina Institute of Higher Education Publication, 33-49.Danish, S. (2019). قوانین اساسی افغانستان[The Constitutions of Afghanistan]. Andisha Foundation Publication, 18-24.Editing at Afghanistan. (2019). شرح کود جزا   [Explanation of penal code]. Bonyad Asia. P. 17.Ehler, R. L, et al. (2013). An Introduction to the Constitutional Law of Afghanistan.Family Structures and Family Law in Afghanistan A Report of the Fact-Finding Mission to. (2005). https://www.mpipriv.de/1187092/mpireport_on_family_structures_and_family_law_in_afghanistan.pdfFarhoumand-Sims, C. (2009). CEDAW and Afghanistan. Journal of International Women’s Studies, 11(1), 136–156. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/48828409.pdfFrogh, W. (2009). Gender-based Violence in Afghanistan An Annual Report by Afghan Women’s Network , Kabul.https://www.aidsdatahub.org/sites/default/files/resource/gender-based-violenceafghanistan.pdfGross, E. (2009). Reconstructing Afghanistan: Is the “West” eclipsing the “International Community”? Sicherheit & Frieden, 27(2), 79–83. https://doi.org/10.5771/0175-274x-2009-2-79Hakimi, M. (2020). Afghanistan’s Law on Elimination of Violence Against Women Afghanistan’s Law on Elimination of Violence Against Women. Northwestern Journal of Human Rights Northwestern Journal of Human Rights, 18.  https://law.stanford.edu/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Mehdi-J.-Hakimi-Northwestern-Journal-of-Human-Rights-Article-Winter-2020.pdfHashimi, G. (2016). Defending the Principle of Legality in Afghanistan: Toward a Unified Interpretation of Article 130 to the Afghan Constitution. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2817307Hozyainova, A. (2014). Sharia and Women’s Rights in Afghanistan. U.S. Institute of Peace. P.3Knust, M., & Afshar, R. (2006). The Case of an Afghan Apostate -The Right to a Fair Trial Between Islamic Law and Human Rights in the Afghan Constitution. https://www.mpil.de/files/pdf3/mpunyb_13_knust1.pdfMahdian, A. & Talab, M.R. (2019). The personal status of the Shiites in Afghanistan and the extent of its alignment with Jafari fiqh ( the Heritage section ). Biannual Journal of Comparative Studies on the School of Jurisprudence and its Principles, 2(1), 54-70.Mahmoudi, S. (2004). The Sharî’a in the new Afghan constitution: Contradiction or complement? ZaöR, 64, 867-880. Max Planck Manual on Family Law in Afghanistan. (2012). https://www.mpipriv.de/1187062/max_planck_manual_on_afghan_family_law_english.pdfMir, H. S. (2004). The Implementation of Constitutional Human Rights in Afghanistan. Journal of Thermophysics and Heat Transfer, 11(3), 14.Mohammad, R. A., & Abbasi, Z. (2015). The Age of Criminal Responsibility in Children: Some of Islamic Views. . DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals). 777-787Mojaddadi, N. N., & Sayed, M. (2022). A Critical Analysis Of Governance Under The 2004 Constitution Of Afghanistan. Journal of Higher Education and Development Studies (JHEDS), 2(1), 66–86. https://doi.org/10.59219/jheds.v2i1.8Muhannad, F. E. (2024). Gender Equality: In the Light of Quran and Sunnah Volume. International Journal of Religion, 5(12), 311–328. https://doi.org/10.61707/hq11rn27Munadi, S. M. (2006, March 26). Apostasy case faces setback. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2006/03/26/world/asia/apostasy-case-faces-setback.htmlNabi, Z (2024). Afghanasamai.com. http://www.afghanasamai.com/afghanasamai%20ausgabe5/Qanezada%20Abdul%20Rahman%20Afghanasamai.htm News, A. (2006, March 22). Bush pressures Afghanistan over Christian convert case. ABC News. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2006-03-23/bush-pressures-afghanistan-over-christian-convert/825780NPR. (2006, March 22). Afghan Christian Convert Faces Death Penalty for Beliefs. NPR. https://www.npr.org/2006/03/22/5294096/afghan-christian-convert-faces-death-penalty-for-beliefsOates, L. (2009). A CLOSER LOOK The Policy and Law-Making Process Behind the Shiite Personal Status Law. AREU. https://www.refworld.org/reference/countryrep/areu/2009/en/69240Okpe, V. V., Othman, M. F., & Osman, N. B. (2021). An Assessment into Women Political Participation In Malaysian Democratic Governance. e-Bangi: Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, 18(5), 21-36.Qazi Zada, S. (2020). Legislative, institutional and policy reforms to combat violence against women in Afghanistan. Indian Journal of International Law, 59(1). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40901-020-00116-xRahimi, H. (2022). Remaking of Afghanistan: How the Taliban are Changing Afghanistan’s Laws and Legal Institutions. Nus.edu.sg. https://www.isas.nus.edu.sg/papers/remaking-of-afghanistan-how-the-taliban-are-changing-afghanistans-laws-and-legal-institutions/Raihanah, M. M., Hashim, R. S., & Noraini Md Yusof. (2015). Islamophobia And Muslim Minorities in Post 9/11 Women’s Fiction. E-Bangi: Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities, 12(2015), 10.Rasikh. M. (2017). Non-Violation of Islamic Law Under the Afghan Constitution. Journal of Afghan Legal Studies, 1(2), 194-211.Rasooli, M.A. (2017). روش ها و اصول قانون ګذاری [legislative Drafting: Principles and techniques]. Al-Sead PublicationRazayi. G. (2022). حقوق مالی زن در شریعت اسلامی و قوانین افغانستان[ Financial rights of women in Shariah and the laws of Afghanistan]. Findings Of Law, 2(4), 26-58.Roder. T.J. (2017) Complementary and Conflict: State, Islamic and Customary Justice in Afghanistan. Journal of Afghan Legal Studies, 1(2), 214-243.Rofii, A. (2020). Islam, Islamic Law and Constitution Making: International and Domestic Engagement in the Constitution-Making Process in Afghanistan. Mazahib, 19(1). https://doi.org/10.21093/mj.v19i1.2142Rubin, B. R. (2004). Crafting a Constitution for Afghanistan. Journal of Democracy, 15(3), 5–19. https://doi.org/10.1353/jod.2004.0051Saeed, L. (2022). Analysis of Article 130 of the Afghan Constitution. Islam, Custom and Human Rights: A Legaland Empirical Study of Criminal Cases in Afghanistan After the 2004 Constitution, 65-78.Salimi, K. M. (2007). Judge of the appellate court in Herat province, Fair Trail Seminar. Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law.Sayed Sikandar Shah Haneef, Najibah Mohd Zin, Mek Wok Mahmud, & Iium Press. (2016). Issues on harmonization of human rights in Islam. Iium Press.Shahram, A.& MacQueen, B. (2008). Islam and Human Rights in Practice. Routledge.Saiful, T., et al. (2020, March 13). Gender Equality Perspective and Women Position in Islam. Atlantis Press. https://doi.org/10.2991/assehr.k.200306.212.Tadjdini, A. (2012). Constitutionalisation of Islam in Afghanistan, Iran and Iraq: A Step Back for the Position of Human Rights? Nordic Journal of Human Rights, 29(04), 353–368. https://doi.org/10.18261/issn1891-814x-2011-04-04Tāhā, J. F. A, & Roberts, N. (2012). Apostasy in Islam: a historical and scriptural analysis. International Institute of Islamic Thought.Tarzi, A. (2017). Afghanistan: Apostasy Case Reveals Constitutional Contradictions. Eurasianet. https://eurasianet.org/afghanistan-apostasy-case-reveals-constitutional-contradictionsThier, J. (2003). The Making of a Constitution in Afghanistan State Reconstruction and International Engagement in Afghanistan Panel IV: Re-Establishing a Legal System “The Making of a Constitution in Afghanistan.” https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/129103/thier.pdfThier, J. (2006). The Making of a Constitution in Afghanistan. NYLS Law Review, 51(3), 558–579. https://digitalcommons.nyls.edu/nyls_law_review/vol51/iss3/5/Thomas, J., & Harden, A. (2008). Methods for the thematic synthesis of qualitative research in systematic reviews. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 8(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2288-8-45Tilmann J. R. (2007). Complementary and Conflict: State, Islamic and Customary Justice in Afghanistan. Journal of Afghan Legal Studies, 2(1), 220.United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan and United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights. (2018). Injustice and Impunity Mediation of Criminal Offences of Violence against Women. (pp. 1–48). https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Countries/AF/UNAMA_OHCHR_EVAW_Report2018_InjusticeImpunity29May2018.pdfWafa, A. W. (2006, March 25). Preachers in Kabul Urge Execution of Convert to Christianity. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2006/03/25/world/asia/preachers-in-kabul-urge-execution-of-convert-to-christianity.htmlWang, C. (2014). Rule of law in Afghanistan: enabling a constitutional framework for local accountability. Harv.Int'l LJ, 55, 211.Welle, D. (2006, March 27). Afghan Court Drops Case Against Christian Convert. Deutsche Welle. https://www.dw.com/en/afghan-court-drops-case-against-christian-convert/a-1945495Worsi. M. (2020). برابری در نظام حقوقی افغانستان  [the principle of equality in the legal system of Afghanistan]. Adalat, 22(215). P 69-88.قاضی افغان اظهارات مقام های غربی را دخالت درامور داخلی افغانستان دانست [ the Afghan judge consider the recent statements of western officials interference in the Afghan internal affairs]. Khabar Kozari Jamhori Islami. https://www.irna.ir/news/6276042.